Total Pageviews

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

The Biological Impulse and the Role of Geography

One of the most convincing arguments against religion, at least religions that make very specific claims about how the universe works, is the fact that geographical location plays the biggest role in what type of superstitious belief system an individual has.  And another strong argument is this: While I admit that human beings are inherently religious (well, inherently superstitious, with superstitiousness manifesting itself as religion), human beings are not inherently Christian, or inherently Muslim, or Buddhist, or anything else.  We are prone to superstition because of the way our brains perceive the world, and we are prone to ritual because of the evolutionary advantages it confers on social animals.  These two things combined predispose us to be religious.  I will clarify what I mean in the following paragraphs.

The Biological Impulse
Our Origins
We are a product of evolution.  Our nervous system, which houses our consciousness, was molded by natural selection to do one thing: help us live as long as possible.  Well, technically, to help us live long enough to reach the age where we can reproduce, and thus pass our genes on to the next generation.  Our consciousness results from nothing more than a series of electrochemical signals travelling through a complex neural network.  If you believe that this is selling human consciousness short, then you are trying to impose your subjective view on objective reality.  You may want human consciousness to add up to more than electrochemical signals, but that has no effect on whether it actually does.  What you should not do, is is take human consciousness for granted.  It is, in my opinion, the most beautiful of all natural phenomena.  Just because there is no soul per se, this does not imply that consciousness is unimportant.  It does mean that you can stop worrying about the possibility of your soul spending an eternity suffering the miseries of hellfire and damnation, if you happen to pick the wrong set of rituals to participate in during your life.

Narratives and Connections (The Root of Superstition)
So, back to evolution.  Evolution by natural selection is the process by which our brains, and thus our minds, came into being.  As mentioned above, our brains/minds have been evolved in order to help us reach the age of baby-making.  In order to survive, it is important for a human mind to understand things, to make connections, to create narratives.   (I specify human mind because it is unique in the animal kingdom, and much of what I'm going to say only applies to human minds.  I will do a post later on the evolutionary turning points that the human mind underwent in becoming the superior processing machine it is today.)  We are afraid of the unknown, for obvious evolutionary reasons, and once our brains got to the point where they could create narratives and relay them via language, we spent no time in spinning any tale we could to explain the mysteries we saw around us.  This is evidenced in tribal belief systems as well as in the mainstream religions.  It seems that when we gained the ability to create narratives, we became addicted to them.  Stories were created to explain everything, even when the stories had no basis in reality.  This is the root cause of superstition in general.  The ability to create narratives and see connections serves a vital evolutionary role.  It allows one person to tell another person that the blue berries on the bush with the spiky leaves is poisonous.  It allows the person who found the dead body of his friend, next to a spiky-leaved bush, with blue berry-filled vomit on the ground, say to himself "he must have eaten those berries, and those berries must have killed him. I must not eat those berries."  This helps him and his fellow tribe members survive, which when you get down to it is enabling him to pass on his genes.  Natural selection therefore does work on this ability.  The problem with this is that we really are addicted to stories.  We want reality to make sense, so our brains try to find ways to perceive it as a sensical place.  Some of the methods the brain uses to do this include the superstitious stories of religion.  Connections are made where there really are no connections.  Narratives are used to explain phenomena that science does not understand yet (notice yet; the domain of superstition shrinks as science progresses.  Thor is no longer required to explain lightning, now that we Know about electricity), when clearly these narratives explain nothing about the actual phenomena.

Ritual: A Community Exercise
Natural selection not only has reason to select for brains that have the capability to make connections and create narratives, but it also has reason to select for behaviors that more strongly knit the communities of social animals together.  This is why human beings have institutionalized forms of ritual in every culture around the world, and it is also where our basic sense of morality comes from (but that is another post entirely).  Not only does ritual cause societies to be more tightly-knit, but in most cases it builds a hierarchy of order into the culture, which helps with survival as well.  This is why the military has a strict chain of command: in life-and-death scenarios, groups of individuals need leaders and obedient followers in order for the group to act decisively and quickly.  Obviously, this aids in survival.


The Role of Geography
Are you religious?  If you are, is your religion the same as your parents'?  If not, is it at least the same "flavor?"  Chances are, it is.  The vast majority of religious people inherited their beliefs.  They have believed what they believe since they were very young, since they were too young to even consider the merits of their beliefs.  How can heritability give credence to a belief?  The only way to be an intellectually honest adult is to pick your beliefs based on their merits, that is, based on their truth value, and on their ability to rationally explain the world around you.  How likely is it, that out of the thousands of religions the world has seen, you were born into a family who already believes the correct one?  If so, you hit the jackpot.  It is extremely lucky for you, to never have to change your belief system once in your entire life, because you were taught the correct one starting when you where five years old!

Conversions
You may say, in response to my point about the vast majority of people inheriting their religious beliefs, "But what about conversions?"  Well, yes, individuals do convert.  They convert between different religions, and between different flavors of the same religion.  But this is rare, and it happens every which way.  That is to say, the net flux of converts does not really favor any of the big religions.  It is true that the number of Muslims is rapidly growing, and that Muslims will soon outnumber Christians, but this is not due to conversion.  It is due to higher birth rates in Muslim countries, which conveniently backs up my point about heritability: the vast majority of babies born to Muslim parents in Muslim countries will grow up to be followers of Islam.  To my knowledge, non-religiousness/agnosticism/atheism is the fastest growing category of belief due to conversion(1).  That is, due to adults weighing the merits of different belief systems and making decisions based on research and thought.

1. sources
http://www.positiveatheism.org/india/s1990c48a.htm
http://evidenceforchristianity.blogspot.com/2009/03/growth-of-atheism.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_atheism (notice the graph halfway down the page. i know it focuses only on Britain, but it represents a general trend)