I will be using Desmond Lee’s translation, from Penguin Classics.
Brief Context of Plato
Plato (427-347 BCE) is one of the most influential philosophers ever to have lived. His mentor, Socrates, is said to be the ‘founder’ of philosophy (so much so that all writers before him are grouped together as the ‘Presocratics’), but did not leave behind any writings. Plato, however, was a prolific writer and is actually quite a joy to read. The first time I read Plato was when I read the Apology for my introductory philosophy class. I unexpectedly found him easy to understand. He writes with a sort of poetic, dramatic edge that gives more life to his material than there would be otherwise. Plato lived in democratic Athens, which was in the most real sense a pure democracy. Eligible citizens drew lots for random participation in the government for a specified time period. As a result, a random group of Athenians was in charge of diplomacy, war, economic policy, creating and upholding the law, city planning, etc. at any given time. Plato hated democracy as a result of the fickle nature of the citizenry of Athens. Could you imagine the government being run by a group of average people picked off the streets? No requirements of knowledge or skill existed. It was a small-minded, greedy, thoughtless lot that sentenced Socrates to death, bankrupted Athens, and kept pushing the city farther and farther away from what it was in the Golden Age when Pericles ruled. As a result, Plato saw democracy as an unredeemable form of government. This shaped how he saw the individual’s place in society. The strong individualism so characteristic of our political philosophy today is not seen in his writing. The Republic is concerned with finding the most just society, which Plato says is the most harmonious society. He therefore says that the harmoniousness of the collective is far and away more important than the individual rights of any citizen or ruler. As will be clarified later, his purpose in sketching out what would be the most just of all societies is to use it as a metaphor to think about the justness (or harmoniousness) of a man’s soul.
Note: Plato uses Socrates as his mouthpiece in this work, so the character of Socrates voices Plato’s views regardless of whether the historical Socrates would have agreed with them. No one knows how much of what Socrates says in Plato’s writings is actually what the historical Socrates believed. When I write something like “Socrates said x,” you should keep this in mind.
The Central Question
The Republic is written as a dialogue between Socrates and some fellow Greeks (mainly and namely Glaucon, Adeimantus, Thrasymacus), and is a very complex book which covers countless topics. It would be foolish for me to attempt to cover everything contained in the pages of this rich work, so I won’t (1). I will only cover the central question asked by Socrates’ interlocutors, namely; how is living a just life inherently better than living an unjust life? For, the characters say, it only seems to be advantageous to have a reputation for justice. Specifically, they state
“it is clear from what they tell me that if I am just, it will bring me no advantage but only trouble and loss, unless I also have a reputation for justice; whereas if I am unjust, but can contrive to get a reputation for justice, I shall have a marvelous time.”
And they ask of Socrates,
“what we want from you is not only a demonstration that justice is superior to injustice, but a description of the essential effects, harmful or otherwise, which each produces on its possessor.”
It is important to emphasize here how the question is framed. There can be no reference to punishment or reward from outside the self. We do not want to know how living a just life is better than living an unjust life because of how other men will treat us with respect and honor, or because of the rewards we will receive from god or the gods in the afterlife or in this life. We want to know how living a just life is better in and of itself. Keep the central question in mind at all times.
The Reason for the Central Metaphor or Allegory
The reason Socrates embarks on the sweeping explanation of the perfect society after which the book is named is to answer the central question metaphorically. He explains why he does so in the following lines:
Socrates: “Justice can be characteristic of an individual or of a community, can it not?”
Adeimantus: “Yes.”
Socrates: “And a community is larger than an individual?”
Adeimantus: “It is.”
Socrates: “We may therefore find justice on a larger scale in the larger entity, and so easier to recognize. I accordingly propose that we start our inquiry with the community, and then proceed to the individual and see if we can find in the conformation of the smaller entity anything similar to what we have found in the larger.”
With this in mind, I will first sketch out Plato’s perfect society, and then explain which elements of that society represent the elements of the soul (2).
The Perfect Society
Creating the perfect society may be, as Socrates suggests, a laughable goal. Nevertheless he pushes onward for the sake of philosophy, for the possibility that doing so may reveal truths about living a just life. Remember, the standard by which we are to judge a society is by how harmonious it is. With harmony as our ultimate goal, Socrates concludes that our perfect society must have a clear and conspicuous division into three classes; the Rulers, the Auxiliaries, and the workers/craftsmen, with the separation of these classes strictly enforced (3). In fact, he finds this class separation so important that in his perfect society he deems it justifiable to mislead the common people with a “noble lie” called the Myth of the Metals. In this myth, the gods have added metals to the composition of every individual. Gold is added to the Rulers, silver to the Auxiliaries, and bronze to the workers. Believing this myth, and the fundamental inequality of individuals that it implies, helps the non-rulers accept their positions in society and respect the authority of those above them, thus creating harmony, obedience, and efficiency.
The Rulers
The Rulers have absolute authority over the state. Plato explicitly says that all men are not created equal, and that some people are inherently much better than others (he goes so far as to call this inequality a "natural principle"). The Rulers are the best. They have a right to rule, because in a just society
"The desires of the less respectable majority are controlled by the desires and the wisdom of the superior minority."
Is it any wonder that the upper classes of aristocratic and oligarchic social/governmental systems throughout history have cited Plato when providing justification for their position in the upper crust? This idea is diametrically opposed to the democratic ideal of assigning an equal value to all people. Here is one of the central issues of political philosophy, my friends. Welcome to a discussion of politics that is not full of bullshit.
The requirements for becoming a ruler are intense (and I mean INTENSE). All Rulers are lifelong students of philosophy, veterans of battle, physically healthy, academically skilled, longtime members of the Auxiliary class who have only the good of the state in mind as they rule. This last attribute of selflessness, as Socrates knows, may be impossible to find in the real world. So he sets up elaborate conditions under which the Rulers cannot personally gain from any decisions they make regarding the rule of the state. Rulers have no personal possessions and cannot accumulate wealth. They have no families. In fact, nobody has a family, because children are separated at birth from their mothers and raised communally, so that the only family anyone has is a vast family of fellow citizens. The Rulers live communally in a bleak, communist-style environment. Men and women live together, eat bland food together (no indulgences), are given only what they need to survive and stay sharp. All of this is to ensure that the Rulers are not motivated by personal gain. The existence of the Rulers is not exactly one that many of us would aspire to, but they endure because they are honor- and duty-bound as the best of the best to rule their state. And because it is imperative that the Rulers are composed of the best of the best, there are no limitations to who can be a Ruler. Class mobility is easy and necessary if a child shows promise. Women are encouraged to compete for spots just as men are (Plato was pretty much alone in his time in believing that a woman may be as capable as a man in performing the traditionally male tasks of ruling, philosophizing, fighting in the military, etc.). Again, the ruling class has absolute authority and only acts for the good of the community at large.
The Auxiliaries
The Auxiliary class carries out the orders of the Rulers. Just like the Rulers, they live an austere, simplistic life devoid of personal gain. Plato thought private property was the primary reason that rulers sacrifice public good to private gain, so the Guardians (see footnote 3) must not be subject to such temptation. The Auxiliary class actually carries out the functions of government under the guidance of the Rulers, so that the Rulers can spend their time deciding which policies are best for the state. They are the military officers, the police, the executors of executive actions, etc. Everything they do is commanded by the Rulers and is for the good of the state. As mentioned above, a requirement for becoming a Ruler is to serve honorably as an Auxiliary.
The Workers
This class is composed of the common people. They live in a way similar to the way you and I live. They are free to own property and accumulate wealth. This class can indulge themselves with alcohol, sumptuous food, music, you name it. Except, what about sex? Hilariously, Plato believes that sex must be and can be successfully regulated in the perfect society. A eugenics program must be set up to create the best people possible. The Rulers will oversee this process and manipulate the Workers with force, propaganda, and outright dishonesty for the good of society as a whole. Here are two examples of how the Workers may be regulated and manipulated:
“it would be a sin either for mating or anything else in a truly happy society to take place without regulation”
And
“our Rulers will have to employ a great deal of fiction and deceit for the benefit of their subjects; and you will remember that we agreed that they might be used as a kind of medicine.”
Such are the powers that the Guardians have over the Workers. Our modern sentiments of individualism strongly oppose such absolute power by the ruling class. But, Plato would argue, nothing is done that is not for the benefit of the community. And since the Rulers are motivated correctly, and are basically geniuses, the policies of the state create a community where every person has no choice but to be happy.
How the Just Soul Relates to the Perfect Society
Socrates relates the three classes in his perfect society to the "three elements of the soul." As the following discussion unfolds, remember that Plato's connotation of the word "soul" is different than our own; what he is doing at core is an analysis of the psychology of motivation, and his analogy has to do with how the parts of a soul relate to each other and the whole.
Appetite
The lowest and least refined part of the soul is the Appetite, analogous to the Workers. The Appetite is considered by Plato to be beastly, a "many-headed monster" with varied and insatiable desires. The Appetite is forever consumed with sex, greed, hunger, power, violence, etc. and has no self-regulation. If a man allows his Appetite dominion over his soul, he will frantically follow whims of fleeting importance, ruining himself in the process. The Appetite does not have a capacity for long-term planning or self control. All it knows is desire. With respect to a man of this nature,
"His mind will be burdened with servile restrictions, because the best elements in him will be enslaved and completely controlled by a minority of the lowest and most lunatic impulses."
That is not to say that the appetite is a part of the self to be completely stifled. The appetite can do some of what it wants to do, under the guidance of the higher parts of the soul. A just man will not allow his Appetite to roam free. He knows it must be controlled by the higher parts of himself.
Ambition
Plato's second tier of the soul could be translated as Ambition or Spirit, analogous to the Auxiliary. It is a part of the soul that helps in the fight to control the appetite. He says Ambition is like a lion, fierce and honorable. It is the part of a marathon runner that keeps pushing at the end of the race, the part of the warrior that tells him to keep fighting even though he is gravely wounded. It is the driving force that men of great ability use to propel themselves to the heights of success; a powerful force of nature in the self to be harnessed and used to great advantage.
Reason/The Rational Element
Just as the Rulers have absolute control over the Auxiliaries and the Workers in a just society, Reason must in the just man have total, unrelenting control over Ambition and Appetite. In a just man, Reason makes the over-arching decisions regarding the overall direction of his life. Ambition (Spirit) comes to the aid of Reason:
"So the Reason ought to rule, having the wisdom and foresight to act for the whole, and the Spirit ought to obey and support it."
"Certainly."
"And this concord between them is effected, as we said, by a combination of intellectual and physical training, which tunes up the Reason by a training in the rational argument and higher studies, and tones down and soothes the element of Spirit by harmony and rhythm."
"Certainly."
"When these two elements have been so brought up, and trained and educated to their proper function, they must be put in charge of Appetite, which forms the greater part of each man's make-up and is naturally insatiable. They must prevent it taking its fill of the so-called physical pleasures, for otherwise it will get too large and strong to mind its own business and will try to subject and control the other elements, which it has no right to do, and so wreck the life of all of them."
Such is the relation between the three parts of the soul. The difficult task for each of us is to set our souls in order, and put the Rational self in control. But this is no small task. Discord between Appetite and Reason is ever-threatening. Have you ever done something you knew you shouldn't, because of the instant gratification you got from it? This is Appetite winning over Reason. Have you ever held back from doing something you wanted to do very badly, because you knew that in the long run you would be better off if you abstained? Such is the case when Reason is in control of Appetite. "I really want to eat this cookie, but I won't because I'm trying to lose weight." Someone who says this to themselves has put Reason in charge, and subdued the base, instinctual hunger drive of the Appetite.
So how does one strengthen their Reason into a formidable captor, able to keep the Appetite in check? Plato says "training in the rational argument and higher studies" is the path to take. These "higher studies" of which he speaks have to do with his metaphysics (see the Allegory of the Cave, The Divided Line, the metaphor of the Sun), but in general the higher studies are learning about the eternal, unchanging truths behind the constant flux of the world around us (you may have heard of the Platonic Forms). According to Plato, the true philosopher sees the everlasting eternal principles that govern the universe. This is why he loves mathematics: he believes them to be the doorway into a certain category of eternal truths. For example, one mathematical eternal truth would be that the angles of a triangle add up to 180 degrees. Many things in the universe may change, but can you imagine a time in the future when a triangle's angles do not add up to 180 degrees? Is that even possible? Can there ever be a circle whose circumference is not 2 X 3.14 X the radius? Will the Pythagorean Theorem ever cease to be true? Plato says no. He also says that there are other eternal truths (Forms) that share the same ontological status with mathematical laws.He says that there are Forms of Justice, of Happiness, of The Good, and that training oneself to be able to see these eternal Forms should be the lifelong goal of the philosopher, of the Rational in all of us. Only by doing so can we strengthen the best part of us enough to truly be in control of the baser parts.
How This Applies Today
Plato thinks that each one of us has these three parts in us, and constantly struggle with their clashing interests within us as we go about our lives. Do you agree with him? Do you know people who have put Reason in control? Do you know anyone who has let Appetite take the reigns? Let me give you an example of each:
Plato's Just Man of 2012
Let's call him Dr. Levitt. He is a middle-aged man who has a PhD. He is in excellent physical condition. He has a life partner and children, and healthy relationships with them. When he was in school, and he knew he needed to study, his Rational self told him to hit the books, and his Ambition reminded him how much he wanted academic success and all that comes with it. His Appetite kept bugging him to go to the bar with his friends, to get laid, to get drunk. But he doesn't, because his Reason is in control. Instead, he aces his test. He goes to the gym every morning. He eats a healthy diet. His Appetite wants more sleep, wants to eat a double bacon cheeseburger every day. But he wakes up and eats vegetables, because his Rational self knows how much better he will be in the long run. When conflict arises within his immediate family, he tries to compromise, to resolve issues calmly. He does not abuse his wife and children even though he is in a position of power. He does not beat his wife when they have a disagreement. His Reason knows what consequences that would bring, and, more importantly, he is acquainted with the Form of Justice, and the Form of the Good. He knows that he must aspire to these Forms if he is to live a truly happy life. Such is Plato's ideal man.
Plato's Lowest Kind of Man (of 2012)
Let's call him Steve. Steve is a druggie. Every waking moment he is either high or searching desperately for a way to get his hands on the next hit. His Appetite is completely in control. All he wants is to feel the heroine rushing into his vein, to drift off into a world of momentary, chemically-induced bliss. He is broke, he can't hold a job, he has meaningless sex with any willing or unwilling partner he can take advantage of. He is a slave to his basic instincts; he cannot rise above them. His health is in decline, and his Rational self is there, in the back of his mind, telling him that if he doesn't stop living this way, he will die an early death after living a pathetic life. But his Appetite smothers it. All is eclipsed by the next hit, by the next woman he will bone, by the next bottle of vodka. Such is the man who lets Appetite rule his life, who sacrifices the better part of himself to his baser elements.
According to Plato, the only way to true happiness is to let the highest part of the self rule. The highest part of the self has the greatest potential for happiness, and so it is a tragedy to let the lowest elements take control and deprive the noble self of its great potential. I myself find Plato's analysis to be insightful (I almost want to say "insightful as fuck," but I'm trying to keep this blog classy). After reading the Republic, I have an entirely new perspective from which to view the world and people around me. More importantly, I have a new perspective from which to view my own decision-making process and behavior. Perhaps it is appropriate to think of the Republic like an ancient philosopher's version of the Michael Jackson song "Man in the Mirror." Do you know why you make the decisions you make? If you frequently make bad decisions, why is that so? Maybe if we all ruled our appetitive selves with our higher selves, this world wouldn't have as many problems as it does.
- Plato lays out his metaphysics in his famous Allegory of the Cave, the Divided Line, and the metaphor of the Sun. I highly recommend checking those out.
- Although Plato believed in an immortal soul, it is inappropriate to attach the religious connotation that the word has today to Plato’s use of it here. His concern here has more to do with psychology.
- The Rulers and the Auxiliaries are grouped together into the Guardians. The workers/craftsmen, although the lowest class in this system, should not be thought of as the lower class in our society is thought of. This class in Socrates’ system includes lawyers, doctors, wealthy business owners, etc. Pretty much anybody who practices a trade to make a profit.
Epic Quotes
Note: what appears in brackets below I have added for the sake of clarity.
- “Those, therefore, who have no experience of wisdom and goodness, and do nothing but have a good time, spend their life straying between the bottom and middle in our illustration, and never rise higher to see or reach the true top, nor achieve any real fulfillment or sure and unadulterated pleasure. They bend over their tables, like sheep with heads bent over their pasture and eyes on the ground, they stuff themselves and copulate, and in their greed for more they kick and butt each other with hooves and horns of steel, and kill each other because they are not satisfied, as they cannot be while they fill with unrealities a part of themselves which is itself unreal and insatiable.”
- “We must learn not to hold our hurts and waste our time crying, like children who’ve bumped themselves, but to train our mind to cure our ills and rectify our lapses as soon as it can, banishing sorrow by healing it.”
- Cephalus, a very old man, responding to Socrates’ question about how old age “blunts one’s enjoyment of physical pleasures,” says, “I was once present when someone was asking the poet Sophocles about sex, and whether he was still able to make love to a woman; to which he replied, ‘Don’t talk about that; I am glad to have left it behind me and escaped from a fierce and frenzied master.’”
- Socrates, speaking of how good men should serve in government even though they are reluctant, said, “the worst penalty for refusal [to govern] is to be governed by someone worse than themselves,” and “in a city of good men there might well be as much competition to avoid power as there now is to get it.”
- Glaucon expresses a view to be fleshed out further in the 1600’s by Thomas Hobbes in The Leviathan when he says “no man is just of his own free will, but only under compulsion, and. . . no man thinks justice pays him personally, since he will always do wrong when he gets the chance.”
- Adeimantus quotes Hesiod: “Evil can men attain easily and in companies: the road is smooth and her dwelling near. But the gods have decreed much sweat before a man reaches virtue.”
- Adeimantus explains the common view: “People are unanimous in hymning the worth of self-control or justice, but think they are difficult to practice and call for hard work, while self-indulgence and injustice are easy enough to acquire, and regarded as disgraceful only by convention; wrong on the whole pays better than right, they say, and they are ready enough to call a bad man happy and respect him both in public and private provided he is rich and powerful, while they have no respect for the poor and powerless, and despise him, even though they agree that he is the better man.”
- The original source of the phrase “Platonic love” is the following statement, where Socrates expresses the view that true love would be defiled by sex: “[love] can therefore have no contact with this sexual pleasure, and lovers whose mutual love is true must neither of them indulge in it.”
- While explaining the proper role of medicine in society, Socrates says “it’s disgraceful too to need a doctor not only for injury or regular disease, but because by leading the kind of idle life we have described we have filled our bodies with gases and fluids, like a stagnant pool, and driven the medical profession to invent names for our diseases, like flatulence and catharr,” and “all their cures and medicines have no effect – except to make their ailments worse and more complicated – yet they live in hope that every new medicine they are recommended will restore them to health (diet pills, anyone?),” and Glaucon says “there’s nothing worse than this fussiness about one’s health, in excess of normal physical training. It’s tiresome in the home, as well as in the army or in a sedentary civilian office.”
- “People of good character seem simple when they are young, and are easily taken in by dishonesty – because they have nothing corresponding in themselves to give them a sympathetic understanding of wickedness.”
- Socrates explains the need for both physical and mental training: “they are not intended the one to train the body, the other the mind, except incidentally, but to ensure a proper harmony between energy and initiative on the one hand and reason on the other, by tuning each to the right pitch.”
- “There is a better and a worse element in the personality of each individual, and. . . when the naturally better element controls the worse then the man is said to be ‘master of himself’ and a term of praise.”
- Some sayings are very, very old (remember this was written in 375 B.C.): “As the saying goes, ‘anything that is worthwhile is difficult.’”
- Expressing a point of view very controversial and unique at the time of Plato’s writing, Socrates states: “We shall have to train the women also, then, in both kinds of skill, and train them for war as well, and treat them in the same way as men.”
- “I think a lot of people. . . fail to see the difference between scoring points in debate and arguing seriously.”
- “I expect you’ve noticed too how those who love honor, if they can’t get command of any army, will take a battalion, and if the more important people don’t look up to them, are content if the smaller fry do, so passionately keen are they on prestige of any sort.”
- “One trait in the philosopher’s character we can assume is his love of any branch of learning that reveals eternal reality, the realm unaffected by the vicissitudes of change and decay.”
- Speaking of the true philosopher, Socrates says “he will be self-controlled and not grasping about money. Other people are more likely to worry about the things which make men so eager to get and spend money.”
- On how conformity is pushed onto the young as they are growing up: “Isn’t it really the public who say this who are themselves Sophists on a grand scale, and give a complete training to young and old, men and women, turning them into just the sort of people they want? . . . Won’t [an adolescent] be swamped by the flood of popular praise and blame, and carried away with the stream till he finds himself agreeing with popular ideas of what is admirable or disgraceful, behaving like the crowd and becoming one of them?”
- Referring to a rich, good looking, high and mighty man who is full of senseless ostentation and inane pride: “he’s completely lacking in understanding, and won’t acquire it unless he works for it like a slave.”
- On how men who do the most evil are gifted individuals: “it is men so gifted who inflict the deepest injuries on communities and individuals, and indeed, if their inclinations run that way, do them the greatest good. Small natures never do much good or harm either.”
- “All great undertakings are risky, and, as they say, what is worthwhile is always difficult.”
- On lawyers/sophists: “Nor have they heard enough free and fair discussion, which strains every nerve to discover the truth out of sheer desire for knowledge, and gives a wide berth to subtle tricks of argument whose only object is to make an effect or contest a point, whether in law-court or lecture-room.”
- “The true philosopher. . . whose mind is on higher realities, has not time to look at the affairs of men, or to take part in their quarrels with all the jealousy and bitterness they involve. His eyes are turned to contemplate fixed and immutable realities, a realm where there is no injustice done or suffered, but all is reason and order, and which is the model which he imitates and to which he assimilates himself as far as he can.”
- On how the uneducated are not fit to rule and how the intellectuals do not wish to rule: “The uneducated have no single aim in life to which all their actions, public and private, are to be directed; the intellectuals will take no practical action of their own accord, fancying themselves to be out of this world in some kind of earthly paradise.”
- While explaining his metaphysics, Plato writes of the beauty of what we call physics: “The stars that decorate the sky, though we rightly regard them as the finest and most perfect of visible things, are far inferior, just because they are visible, to the true realities; that is, to the true relative velocities, in pure numbers and perfect figures [or equations], of the orbits and what they carry in them, which are perceptible to reason and thought but not visible to the eye.”
- While speaking of how to find truth via reason and logic (dialectic), Socrates expresses a view that reminds me very much of Renee Descartes’ methodological skepticism in The Meditations: “Dialectic, in fact, is the only procedure which proceeds by the destruction of assumptions to the very first principle, so as to give itself a firm base.”
- “The mind shirks mental hardship more than physical; it touches it more nearly, whereas physical labor it can share with the body.”
- “Compulsory physical exercise does no harm to the body, but compulsory learning never sticks in the mind.”
- On becoming truly wise: “[intelligent individuals must] bring together the disconnected subjects they studied in childhood and take a comprehensive view of their relationship with each other and with the nature of reality.”
- “You must have noticed how young men, after their first taste of argument, are always contradicting people just for the fun of it; they imitate those whom they hear cross-examining each other, and themselves cross-examine other people like puppies hwo love to pull and tear at anyone within reach.”
- The following conversation between Adeimantus and Socrates brilliantly identifies the “drone” class present in society, and how it can give rise to the criminal class:
Socrates: “When our pauper was rich, did he perform any of the useful social functions we’ve just mentioned simply by spending his money? Though he may have appeared to belong to the ruling class, surely in fact he was neither ruling, nor serving society in any other way; he was merely a consumer of goods.”
Adeimantus: “That’s all he was, a mere consumer, whatever he seemed to be.”
Socrates: “Don’t you think we can fairly call him a drone? He grows up in his own home to be a plague to the community, just as a drone grows in its cell to be a plague to the hive.”
Adeimantus: “An apt comparison, Socrates.”
Socrates: “Then you would agree, Adeimantus, that all winged drones have been created by god without stings, but that our two-footed ones vary, some having no stings and some very formidable ones; and that the stingless type end their days as beggars, the stinging type as what we call criminals?”
Adeimantus: “Yes, entirely.”
Socrates: “Obviously, then, in any state where there are beggars there are also, hidden away somewhere about the place, thieves and pick-pockets and temple robbers and all such practitioners of crime.”
- On how most men only pretend to be honest and upstanding for their own gain: “It becomes quite clear that the high reputation for honesty which he has in other business transactions is due merely to a certain respectable constraint which he exercises over his evil impulses, for fear of their effect on his concerns as a whole. There’s no moral conviction, no taming of desire by reason, but only the compulsion of fear.”
- “An excessive desire for liberty at the expense of everything else is what undermines democracy and leads to the demand for tyranny.”
- The following conversation between Adeimantus and Socrates reveals a view of Plato’s that is similar to Ayn Rand’s philosophy; that popular rule results in a corrupt government that taxes (or steals) money from the rich in order to support immoral bureaucrats and fund a welfare state:
Socrates: “The steadiest characters will generally be most successful in making money.”
Adeimantus: “Very likely.”
Socrates: “And the drones find them a plentiful and most convenient source to extract honey from.”
Adeimantus: “There’s not much to be extracted from poor men.”
Socrates: “And so this group, on which the drones batten, are called the rich.”
- “Even in the outwardly most respectable of us there is a terribly bestial and immoral type of desire, which manifests itself particularly in dreams.”
- “Tyrannical characters pass their lives without a friend in the world; they are always either master or slave, and never taste true friendship or freedom.”
- On letting impulses take control: “His mind will be burdened with servile restrictions, because the best elements in him will be enslaved and completely controlled by a minority of the lowest and most lunatic impulses.”
- “We are concerned with the most important of issues, the choice between a good and an evil life.”
- “The wise man speaks with authority when he prefers his own life.”
- “Can it possibly pay anyone to make money by doing wrong, if the result of his so doing is to enslave the best part of himself to the worst?”
- “One must not respect an individual more than the truth.”
- “Nothing is gained by impatience, nor is anything in human life of great consequence.”