One of the major conundrums that plagues society today is the question of whether capitalism or socialism (or some mix) is the best economic system to adopt. Of course, there are different standards by which economic systems can be judged. For example, is an economic system superior if it allows the most freedom, or if it provides the most people with the most amount of happiness? Or, stated another way, by what ethical standards should we judge economic systems by? Some form of Deontological ethics? Utilitarian ethics? Some other value system? The main point of this post is that making these judgements is not as easy as everyone seems to think it is. I daily encounter individuals who are staunchly conservative or staunchly liberal, and don't seem to have any deep reasoning behind their position. They have simply been indoctrinated and have adopted a worldview, without serious thought about the merits of the opposition. When asked to justify their beliefs, the justifications are usually superficial and rotely memorized. The truly disturbing part of this is that I see it in our politicians as much as I do with everybody else. I for one have no idea which is better. I am not an economist, but I do see the valid arguments on both sides. And I do see how having a "mixed" economy undermines the merits of both, mostly due to the toxic government-corporation relationships that plague the system. I am open to (good) arguments, but plead ignorance on this case at least for now, and so should many others, instead of blindly adopting a system they don't know enough about and defending it to their grave for no other reason than stubbornness. This is an incredibly complex topic which very smart individuals have been disagreeing about for a very long time, and I am cautious whenever I see someone who seems too sure of themselves.
This blog is a place for me to express my thoughts on the topics of morality, meaning, religion, philosophy, science, etc.
Total Pageviews
Sunday, November 20, 2011
Sunday, September 18, 2011
The Federalist Papers: How Reading These Essays Informed My Political Thought
I recently read The Federalist Papers in an attempt to educate myself about the political origins of my country. The Federalist Papers are a collection of essays that were written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay in an effort to convince the states to ratify the constitution written at the convention in Philadelphia. That convention was supposed to modify the existing Articles of Confederation in order to make them work better, but came to the conclusion that the Articles were too flawed to fix and that they needed to start from scratch. So they did, and came up with the Constitution.
The idea to read these essays came upon me as I grew more and more fed up with the bombastic political dialogue that relentlessly pummels anyone who pays attention to what is going on politically in the United States. The conservatives and the liberals constantly go at one another, and what is often employed in these political debates is an appeal to the Founding Fathers and the Constitution. Conservatives especially cite them as the basis for their political views, and liberals usually say "you have misinterpreted what they meant." While listening to arguments like this, I found that when these things were said, I could not confidently pick a side and remain intellectually honest because I was uninformed about the basic sources the debaters cited. So, I researched about what I should read to become informed, and came up with The Federalist Papers. Of course, I read the Constitution again to refresh myself as well.
The way that The Federalist Papers affected me was ironic. I thought, because conservatives constantly talk about how great the Constitution is, that I would find information backing up conservatism, but I was completely wrong. The whole purpose of the essays was to convince the people of the states that the Articles of Confederation were way too weak to allow the states to compete with other powerful countries, and that a relatively strong, centralized government with more powers over the states was necessary. The Constitution gives an incredible amount of power to the federal government. Yes, the states are given dominion over themselves, but the federal government is very obviously (according to Madison and Hamilton) given a ton of leeway to do what it deems necessary to protect the Union and cause it to prosper. These essays go through the Constitution, basically line by line, and give the authors' interpretation of exactly what is meant by each section of it. The depth, thoroughness, and scholarly quality are incredible. Madison especially provides enormously convincing arguments backed up by both historical examples (the Greeks, etc.) of failed political systems and contemporary examples of political systems that were failing at the time of his writing. His analysis is breathtakingly powerful.
I very highly recommend reading The Federalist Papers to anyone who is interested in politics, as it provides an essential basic understanding of the creation of our republic, and provides many ideas to chew on that apply as much to our situation today as they did when these essays were written. Frequently as I was going through the essays, I came across a line or paragraph that applied directly to some controversial issue of today. It was very rewarding to know what these Founding Fathers really thought about certain subjects, from their own pens, fully in context, without the filters of politicians or ideologues with obvious ulterior motives.
The idea to read these essays came upon me as I grew more and more fed up with the bombastic political dialogue that relentlessly pummels anyone who pays attention to what is going on politically in the United States. The conservatives and the liberals constantly go at one another, and what is often employed in these political debates is an appeal to the Founding Fathers and the Constitution. Conservatives especially cite them as the basis for their political views, and liberals usually say "you have misinterpreted what they meant." While listening to arguments like this, I found that when these things were said, I could not confidently pick a side and remain intellectually honest because I was uninformed about the basic sources the debaters cited. So, I researched about what I should read to become informed, and came up with The Federalist Papers. Of course, I read the Constitution again to refresh myself as well.
The way that The Federalist Papers affected me was ironic. I thought, because conservatives constantly talk about how great the Constitution is, that I would find information backing up conservatism, but I was completely wrong. The whole purpose of the essays was to convince the people of the states that the Articles of Confederation were way too weak to allow the states to compete with other powerful countries, and that a relatively strong, centralized government with more powers over the states was necessary. The Constitution gives an incredible amount of power to the federal government. Yes, the states are given dominion over themselves, but the federal government is very obviously (according to Madison and Hamilton) given a ton of leeway to do what it deems necessary to protect the Union and cause it to prosper. These essays go through the Constitution, basically line by line, and give the authors' interpretation of exactly what is meant by each section of it. The depth, thoroughness, and scholarly quality are incredible. Madison especially provides enormously convincing arguments backed up by both historical examples (the Greeks, etc.) of failed political systems and contemporary examples of political systems that were failing at the time of his writing. His analysis is breathtakingly powerful.
I very highly recommend reading The Federalist Papers to anyone who is interested in politics, as it provides an essential basic understanding of the creation of our republic, and provides many ideas to chew on that apply as much to our situation today as they did when these essays were written. Frequently as I was going through the essays, I came across a line or paragraph that applied directly to some controversial issue of today. It was very rewarding to know what these Founding Fathers really thought about certain subjects, from their own pens, fully in context, without the filters of politicians or ideologues with obvious ulterior motives.
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
The Biological Impulse and the Role of Geography
One of the most convincing arguments against religion, at least religions that make very specific claims about how the universe works, is the fact that geographical location plays the biggest role in what type of superstitious belief system an individual has. And another strong argument is this: While I admit that human beings are inherently religious (well, inherently superstitious, with superstitiousness manifesting itself as religion), human beings are not inherently Christian, or inherently Muslim, or Buddhist, or anything else. We are prone to superstition because of the way our brains perceive the world, and we are prone to ritual because of the evolutionary advantages it confers on social animals. These two things combined predispose us to be religious. I will clarify what I mean in the following paragraphs.
The Biological Impulse
Our Origins
We are a product of evolution. Our nervous system, which houses our consciousness, was molded by natural selection to do one thing: help us live as long as possible. Well, technically, to help us live long enough to reach the age where we can reproduce, and thus pass our genes on to the next generation. Our consciousness results from nothing more than a series of electrochemical signals travelling through a complex neural network. If you believe that this is selling human consciousness short, then you are trying to impose your subjective view on objective reality. You may want human consciousness to add up to more than electrochemical signals, but that has no effect on whether it actually does. What you should not do, is is take human consciousness for granted. It is, in my opinion, the most beautiful of all natural phenomena. Just because there is no soul per se, this does not imply that consciousness is unimportant. It does mean that you can stop worrying about the possibility of your soul spending an eternity suffering the miseries of hellfire and damnation, if you happen to pick the wrong set of rituals to participate in during your life.
Narratives and Connections (The Root of Superstition)
So, back to evolution. Evolution by natural selection is the process by which our brains, and thus our minds, came into being. As mentioned above, our brains/minds have been evolved in order to help us reach the age of baby-making. In order to survive, it is important for a human mind to understand things, to make connections, to create narratives. (I specify human mind because it is unique in the animal kingdom, and much of what I'm going to say only applies to human minds. I will do a post later on the evolutionary turning points that the human mind underwent in becoming the superior processing machine it is today.) We are afraid of the unknown, for obvious evolutionary reasons, and once our brains got to the point where they could create narratives and relay them via language, we spent no time in spinning any tale we could to explain the mysteries we saw around us. This is evidenced in tribal belief systems as well as in the mainstream religions. It seems that when we gained the ability to create narratives, we became addicted to them. Stories were created to explain everything, even when the stories had no basis in reality. This is the root cause of superstition in general. The ability to create narratives and see connections serves a vital evolutionary role. It allows one person to tell another person that the blue berries on the bush with the spiky leaves is poisonous. It allows the person who found the dead body of his friend, next to a spiky-leaved bush, with blue berry-filled vomit on the ground, say to himself "he must have eaten those berries, and those berries must have killed him. I must not eat those berries." This helps him and his fellow tribe members survive, which when you get down to it is enabling him to pass on his genes. Natural selection therefore does work on this ability. The problem with this is that we really are addicted to stories. We want reality to make sense, so our brains try to find ways to perceive it as a sensical place. Some of the methods the brain uses to do this include the superstitious stories of religion. Connections are made where there really are no connections. Narratives are used to explain phenomena that science does not understand yet (notice yet; the domain of superstition shrinks as science progresses. Thor is no longer required to explain lightning, now that we Know about electricity), when clearly these narratives explain nothing about the actual phenomena.
Ritual: A Community Exercise
Natural selection not only has reason to select for brains that have the capability to make connections and create narratives, but it also has reason to select for behaviors that more strongly knit the communities of social animals together. This is why human beings have institutionalized forms of ritual in every culture around the world, and it is also where our basic sense of morality comes from (but that is another post entirely). Not only does ritual cause societies to be more tightly-knit, but in most cases it builds a hierarchy of order into the culture, which helps with survival as well. This is why the military has a strict chain of command: in life-and-death scenarios, groups of individuals need leaders and obedient followers in order for the group to act decisively and quickly. Obviously, this aids in survival.
The Role of Geography
Are you religious? If you are, is your religion the same as your parents'? If not, is it at least the same "flavor?" Chances are, it is. The vast majority of religious people inherited their beliefs. They have believed what they believe since they were very young, since they were too young to even consider the merits of their beliefs. How can heritability give credence to a belief? The only way to be an intellectually honest adult is to pick your beliefs based on their merits, that is, based on their truth value, and on their ability to rationally explain the world around you. How likely is it, that out of the thousands of religions the world has seen, you were born into a family who already believes the correct one? If so, you hit the jackpot. It is extremely lucky for you, to never have to change your belief system once in your entire life, because you were taught the correct one starting when you where five years old!
Conversions
You may say, in response to my point about the vast majority of people inheriting their religious beliefs, "But what about conversions?" Well, yes, individuals do convert. They convert between different religions, and between different flavors of the same religion. But this is rare, and it happens every which way. That is to say, the net flux of converts does not really favor any of the big religions. It is true that the number of Muslims is rapidly growing, and that Muslims will soon outnumber Christians, but this is not due to conversion. It is due to higher birth rates in Muslim countries, which conveniently backs up my point about heritability: the vast majority of babies born to Muslim parents in Muslim countries will grow up to be followers of Islam. To my knowledge, non-religiousness/agnosticism/atheism is the fastest growing category of belief due to conversion(1). That is, due to adults weighing the merits of different belief systems and making decisions based on research and thought.
1. sources
http://www.positiveatheism.org/india/s1990c48a.htm
http://evidenceforchristianity.blogspot.com/2009/03/growth-of-atheism.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_atheism (notice the graph halfway down the page. i know it focuses only on Britain, but it represents a general trend)
The Biological Impulse
Our Origins
We are a product of evolution. Our nervous system, which houses our consciousness, was molded by natural selection to do one thing: help us live as long as possible. Well, technically, to help us live long enough to reach the age where we can reproduce, and thus pass our genes on to the next generation. Our consciousness results from nothing more than a series of electrochemical signals travelling through a complex neural network. If you believe that this is selling human consciousness short, then you are trying to impose your subjective view on objective reality. You may want human consciousness to add up to more than electrochemical signals, but that has no effect on whether it actually does. What you should not do, is is take human consciousness for granted. It is, in my opinion, the most beautiful of all natural phenomena. Just because there is no soul per se, this does not imply that consciousness is unimportant. It does mean that you can stop worrying about the possibility of your soul spending an eternity suffering the miseries of hellfire and damnation, if you happen to pick the wrong set of rituals to participate in during your life.
Narratives and Connections (The Root of Superstition)
So, back to evolution. Evolution by natural selection is the process by which our brains, and thus our minds, came into being. As mentioned above, our brains/minds have been evolved in order to help us reach the age of baby-making. In order to survive, it is important for a human mind to understand things, to make connections, to create narratives. (I specify human mind because it is unique in the animal kingdom, and much of what I'm going to say only applies to human minds. I will do a post later on the evolutionary turning points that the human mind underwent in becoming the superior processing machine it is today.) We are afraid of the unknown, for obvious evolutionary reasons, and once our brains got to the point where they could create narratives and relay them via language, we spent no time in spinning any tale we could to explain the mysteries we saw around us. This is evidenced in tribal belief systems as well as in the mainstream religions. It seems that when we gained the ability to create narratives, we became addicted to them. Stories were created to explain everything, even when the stories had no basis in reality. This is the root cause of superstition in general. The ability to create narratives and see connections serves a vital evolutionary role. It allows one person to tell another person that the blue berries on the bush with the spiky leaves is poisonous. It allows the person who found the dead body of his friend, next to a spiky-leaved bush, with blue berry-filled vomit on the ground, say to himself "he must have eaten those berries, and those berries must have killed him. I must not eat those berries." This helps him and his fellow tribe members survive, which when you get down to it is enabling him to pass on his genes. Natural selection therefore does work on this ability. The problem with this is that we really are addicted to stories. We want reality to make sense, so our brains try to find ways to perceive it as a sensical place. Some of the methods the brain uses to do this include the superstitious stories of religion. Connections are made where there really are no connections. Narratives are used to explain phenomena that science does not understand yet (notice yet; the domain of superstition shrinks as science progresses. Thor is no longer required to explain lightning, now that we Know about electricity), when clearly these narratives explain nothing about the actual phenomena.
Ritual: A Community Exercise
Natural selection not only has reason to select for brains that have the capability to make connections and create narratives, but it also has reason to select for behaviors that more strongly knit the communities of social animals together. This is why human beings have institutionalized forms of ritual in every culture around the world, and it is also where our basic sense of morality comes from (but that is another post entirely). Not only does ritual cause societies to be more tightly-knit, but in most cases it builds a hierarchy of order into the culture, which helps with survival as well. This is why the military has a strict chain of command: in life-and-death scenarios, groups of individuals need leaders and obedient followers in order for the group to act decisively and quickly. Obviously, this aids in survival.
The Role of Geography
Are you religious? If you are, is your religion the same as your parents'? If not, is it at least the same "flavor?" Chances are, it is. The vast majority of religious people inherited their beliefs. They have believed what they believe since they were very young, since they were too young to even consider the merits of their beliefs. How can heritability give credence to a belief? The only way to be an intellectually honest adult is to pick your beliefs based on their merits, that is, based on their truth value, and on their ability to rationally explain the world around you. How likely is it, that out of the thousands of religions the world has seen, you were born into a family who already believes the correct one? If so, you hit the jackpot. It is extremely lucky for you, to never have to change your belief system once in your entire life, because you were taught the correct one starting when you where five years old!
Conversions
You may say, in response to my point about the vast majority of people inheriting their religious beliefs, "But what about conversions?" Well, yes, individuals do convert. They convert between different religions, and between different flavors of the same religion. But this is rare, and it happens every which way. That is to say, the net flux of converts does not really favor any of the big religions. It is true that the number of Muslims is rapidly growing, and that Muslims will soon outnumber Christians, but this is not due to conversion. It is due to higher birth rates in Muslim countries, which conveniently backs up my point about heritability: the vast majority of babies born to Muslim parents in Muslim countries will grow up to be followers of Islam. To my knowledge, non-religiousness/agnosticism/atheism is the fastest growing category of belief due to conversion(1). That is, due to adults weighing the merits of different belief systems and making decisions based on research and thought.
1. sources
http://www.positiveatheism.org/india/s1990c48a.htm
http://evidenceforchristianity.blogspot.com/2009/03/growth-of-atheism.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_atheism (notice the graph halfway down the page. i know it focuses only on Britain, but it represents a general trend)
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Mormons
Ah, Mormonism. Such a multi-faceted, misunderstood, horrible, and fantastic phenomenon. With The Book of Mormon out on Broadway, and the media buzz surrounding Mitt Romney and Jon Huntsman, Mormonism is only going to be getting more attention. But how many people know anything about it? As an ex-Mormon (I dropped out around 16) who has extensive experience with Mormons, I wanted to write about it. Opinions on the religion fall into three main categories; 1) "I am a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, and it is the most wonderful thing in the whole world!" (cue missionary tactics) 2) "Mormons? They are a cult. God help us if their numbers keep growing." 3) "Mormons? Well, I am not a Mormon, but they are free to believe whatever they want to believe." Let's explore these these opinions and their merits.
1) This is typically what you get when a devout Mormon learns that you are not 'a member.' Obviously, my phrasing of opinion 1) conforms to the stereotype of Mormons as overly-bubbly and naive devotees to a way of life that shelters them from the big, bad world and stifles individuality. This stereotype is fully on display in the aforementioned Broadway play, and is not entirely fair. But it is not uncommon in Utah. Even if the member is a more learned, level-headed, thoughtful type of individual, what they will say is just a learned, level-headed, thoughtful-sounding version of the same thing. Built into the fabric of the LDS faith is the notion (even the mandate) that everyone should be a missionary, so it is only logical that they try so earnestly to share the 'amazing awesomeness' of The Church with everyone. Most non-mormons in Utah (myself included) find the omnipresence of part-time missionaries quite overbearing. But, c'est la vie. Mormons will relentlessly promote and stridently defend their religion.
2) This opinion is typical of someone who knows very little about Mormonism, and who has heard from various dubious and unverified sources that backwards, unacceptable practices go on inside the faith. Now, I'm no fan of the faith, or faith in general, but clarifications need to be made. Polygamy is so not a part of the religion anymore. Anyone who has lived around Mormons knows that if you believe the men have multiple wives, you are laughably ignorant. Polygamy was part of the faith, rightly so a controversial one, and talking about it in historical terms is great. But using it as a way to impose an unappealing image on Mormons today is unfair. I'm all for fair/logical/educated arguments against religion, or anything else for that matter, but this does not qualify. As far as the 'Mormons are a cult' thing, it is true that Mormonism has 'cult-ish' tendencies, but I would venture a guess that those tendencies make it only about 10-15% a cult. Yes, I'm using percentages. This is more cultish than I would prefer, but far less cultish than most non-Mormons believe it to be. Besides, many other religions have the same cult-like tendencies. It's how they maintain membership.
3) This is the opinion everybody should have about everybody else's belief system, providing the belief system does not result in actions that harm others. Period. I really need one of those 'coexist' stickers on my car.
Overall, I would say that Mormons are semi-harmless byproducts of the inherent religiosity of the human race. Their beliefs can be strange, but strange beliefs are inevitably found in every faith. Their behavior as a group at times is deplorable (e.g. Prop 8, close-mindedness, condescending righteousness), but in general they are kind people whose religion is fully capable of flourishing in modern times. I guess the whole point of this post is: I'm no fan of Mormonism, or religion at all, and you shouldn't be either, but if you're going to bash Mormons, know what the hell you're talking about, and seriously consider picking another target, because, with very few exceptions, they are not doing much damage to our society.
For fun, I've made a list of pros and cons about living in Utah with the Mormons:
Pros: tons of churches to play basketball in, friendly neighbors (think Wilson in Home Improvement), various delicious jello-based desserts, funeral potatoes, nothing is crowded on Sunday (most importantly theaters)
Cons: omnipresent part-time missionaries, social conservatism, groupthink, close-mindedness, the government is full of Mormons, most of my friends won't hang out on Sundays (when the theaters aren't crowded)
1) This is typically what you get when a devout Mormon learns that you are not 'a member.' Obviously, my phrasing of opinion 1) conforms to the stereotype of Mormons as overly-bubbly and naive devotees to a way of life that shelters them from the big, bad world and stifles individuality. This stereotype is fully on display in the aforementioned Broadway play, and is not entirely fair. But it is not uncommon in Utah. Even if the member is a more learned, level-headed, thoughtful type of individual, what they will say is just a learned, level-headed, thoughtful-sounding version of the same thing. Built into the fabric of the LDS faith is the notion (even the mandate) that everyone should be a missionary, so it is only logical that they try so earnestly to share the 'amazing awesomeness' of The Church with everyone. Most non-mormons in Utah (myself included) find the omnipresence of part-time missionaries quite overbearing. But, c'est la vie. Mormons will relentlessly promote and stridently defend their religion.
2) This opinion is typical of someone who knows very little about Mormonism, and who has heard from various dubious and unverified sources that backwards, unacceptable practices go on inside the faith. Now, I'm no fan of the faith, or faith in general, but clarifications need to be made. Polygamy is so not a part of the religion anymore. Anyone who has lived around Mormons knows that if you believe the men have multiple wives, you are laughably ignorant. Polygamy was part of the faith, rightly so a controversial one, and talking about it in historical terms is great. But using it as a way to impose an unappealing image on Mormons today is unfair. I'm all for fair/logical/educated arguments against religion, or anything else for that matter, but this does not qualify. As far as the 'Mormons are a cult' thing, it is true that Mormonism has 'cult-ish' tendencies, but I would venture a guess that those tendencies make it only about 10-15% a cult. Yes, I'm using percentages. This is more cultish than I would prefer, but far less cultish than most non-Mormons believe it to be. Besides, many other religions have the same cult-like tendencies. It's how they maintain membership.
3) This is the opinion everybody should have about everybody else's belief system, providing the belief system does not result in actions that harm others. Period. I really need one of those 'coexist' stickers on my car.
Overall, I would say that Mormons are semi-harmless byproducts of the inherent religiosity of the human race. Their beliefs can be strange, but strange beliefs are inevitably found in every faith. Their behavior as a group at times is deplorable (e.g. Prop 8, close-mindedness, condescending righteousness), but in general they are kind people whose religion is fully capable of flourishing in modern times. I guess the whole point of this post is: I'm no fan of Mormonism, or religion at all, and you shouldn't be either, but if you're going to bash Mormons, know what the hell you're talking about, and seriously consider picking another target, because, with very few exceptions, they are not doing much damage to our society.
For fun, I've made a list of pros and cons about living in Utah with the Mormons:
Pros: tons of churches to play basketball in, friendly neighbors (think Wilson in Home Improvement), various delicious jello-based desserts, funeral potatoes, nothing is crowded on Sunday (most importantly theaters)
Cons: omnipresent part-time missionaries, social conservatism, groupthink, close-mindedness, the government is full of Mormons, most of my friends won't hang out on Sundays (when the theaters aren't crowded)
Monday, May 30, 2011
Tolerance
So, let's talk about something. Let's talk about tolerance. Tolerance has a very positive connotation when we speak it today. When someone says they are "tolerant," usually what they mean is that they are accepting of the views/beliefs/lifestyles of others. If you asked 100 random people on the street, "Are you a tolerant person," all 100 of them would say yes. Being seen as intolerant through the eyes of others is something that we just cannot let happen. Why? It is from the history of our country, from a lot of "trial and error" by the people and government of the United States, most often with the "error" resulting in massive human suffering. Accusing somebody of being intolerant is a serious attack on their character. But how tolerant are we, really? I see forms of intolerance everywhere. Thankfully, they are not as serious as they used to be. It was fire hoses then, and it is ostracism now. It was not allowing African Americans to vote then, and not allowing same-sex marriage now. It's all the same flavor of stupidity in my book, though. It stems from fearful ignorance. We live in a country (and increasingly a world) where individual liberty is a big deal, which is a terrific thing. I don't know how someone could not be a proponent of individual liberty and call themselves American. But there are opponents to individual liberty everywhere. In some dark corners of the world, these opponents take the form of dictators, drug cartels, corrupt governments, etc. Unfortunately, in our country, the main opponent is religion. Particular types of Christians, to be specific, are the culprits, although in other areas of the world Islam is doing the same thing with much greater success (Saudi Arabia, for example). The attempts by the religious right to impose their belief system on every citizen of the United States through legislation and policy are in my view very dangerous and disturbing. And it all comes from intolerance. Which is a direct result of the teachings of particular Christian faiths that are popular in our country right now. When a person goes to church every Sunday, throughout their life, and certain principles are pounded into their heads with the repetitive and relentless force of a jackhammer, those principles stick. Regardless of their merits, those principles are embedded into the psyche of this person, and they cannot be lifted. Reason cannot touch such principles, and that fact in and of itself is scary. One such principle is "homosexuality is a sin." That's fine. I disagree with it, but that's fine. I have no qualms with someone who believes such a thing. It is their right to believe that and it is their right to be straight. It is not their right to deprive others of the right to be homosexual. It is not their right to pass legislation expressly denying gays the opportunity of marriage and everything that comes with it. Especially because, excluding Biblical verses, there is no reason to believe such a thing. This gets back to what I was saying about individual liberties. There are amazing parallels to be drawn between the problem of racial inequality and the problem of the intolerance of gays. Hell, many of the same arguments the intolerant white folk used in opposition to the civil rights movement are being used by the intolerant religious folk today. Have we not learned? It upsets me. This despicable form of intolerance is inexcusable for decent and educated men and women. Just live your life and let others live theirs as they see fit. As THEY see fit. Not as YOU see fit. It's none of your business.
Before I end this post, I would just like to point out that the above attacks on religion apply only to a small minority of the religious population. Most members of most faiths are good human beings, and I would be a hypocrite if I did not clarify the point that I only take issue with individuals (and religions) who actively discriminate against others, and knowingly cause others to suffer, when they have absolutely no right to do so, because we live in a country where individual liberties are valued. As they should be. I don't give a damn what anyone does, as long as they keep it to themselves and no coersion is involved. Why SHOULD I give a damn? There is no reason why anyone who is thinking reasonably and logically should. The only reason anybody does give a damn is because every Sunday they go faithfully to their preacher, put their head on his table, and invite him to apply his theological jackhammer to their skull. . .
Before I end this post, I would just like to point out that the above attacks on religion apply only to a small minority of the religious population. Most members of most faiths are good human beings, and I would be a hypocrite if I did not clarify the point that I only take issue with individuals (and religions) who actively discriminate against others, and knowingly cause others to suffer, when they have absolutely no right to do so, because we live in a country where individual liberties are valued. As they should be. I don't give a damn what anyone does, as long as they keep it to themselves and no coersion is involved. Why SHOULD I give a damn? There is no reason why anyone who is thinking reasonably and logically should. The only reason anybody does give a damn is because every Sunday they go faithfully to their preacher, put their head on his table, and invite him to apply his theological jackhammer to their skull. . .
Sunday, May 22, 2011
Rejecting the God Hypothesis
So, why don't I believe in god? Is it because I'm heartless? Is it because I am a rebel, someone who enjoys the role of arrogant social pariah? Is it because I get off arguing with people and telling them that they are wrong? Is it because I'm trying to hurt my family? No. My disbelief stems from none of these things, although at some point in my life every one of them has been proposed as a reason for my apostasy. The real reason I believe the things I do is that I value objective, skeptical, scientific inquiry whenever I am searching for truth. I believe this is the best method we have for finding out what the truth is. This seems to be how most individuals search for truth in most cases, but for some reason, huge numbers of people choose not to hold religion to these standards of inquiry. A prosecutor must prove the guilt of a criminal in this way. A researcher must test scientific theories in this way. God gets a pass. Why? And if the standards by which the god hypothesis is tested fall short of even the most basic rigors of honest inquiry, isn't it quite likely that His (for He is, of course, male) existence may be questionable? That's all I'm saying, really. I mean, what evidence is there for His existence, anyway? If we are honestly searching? As far as I can tell, there are two types of answers that people give: 1) anecdotal, emotionally charged stories and testimonies, and 2) the very fact that we and the world exist is evidence in and of itself. As far as 1) goes, it is fairly obvious that this type of evidence has no validity. For one thing, people remember things horribly, and often read meaning into memories and experiences that just has no reason for being there. Also, there is no clear way to separate these stories into categories of "good" or "bad" or "true" or "false." As far as truth value goes, your Christian neighbor's claim that god kept him awake when he was drowsing off at the wheel by speaking to him is inseparable from a Muslim's claim that he feels the presence of Allah when he recites the Koran, and inseparable still from a murderer's (perhaps Abraham's) claim that god ordered him to kill. Sure, the actions that result from each of these claims are different, but how can you say one is true without saying the others are as well? By what standards are you judging these claims? Stories like these are and have been prevalent in every society, at all times, involving thousands of different divinities. They cannot be used to prove god's existence, and if they can, they can be used to prove every god's existence. With regard to 2), I understand this viewpoint a little more. I mean, look at the world. Look at human beings, look at the complex diversity of life around us, look at how earth is set up perfectly to allow living things to flourish. Isn't it too much of a coincidence to just be luck? Well, we are pretty lucky, aren't we? The distance of the earth from the sun, the presence of liquid water, the physical constants of the universe that allow everything to be the way it is, aren't these proof of a divine being setting up conditions for we Homo sapiens to live comfortably? I wouldn't say so. This whole line of reasoning is actually. . . unreasonable. We exist. Therefore, everything that had to happen to allow us to exist, happened. Are we lucky to exist? Sure. But we do exist. What are the odds that the earth is just the right distance from the sun? Well, from where we stand, 100%. It is the right distance from the sun. That's why we exist. The earth doesn't sit at its position so we can exist. The point of view that the universe is the way it is so we can exist is very egotistical and self-centered. Not only that, but science continues to make this viewpoint seem more and more foolish. At first, it was thought that the everything revolved around the earth, because we live on the earth, and we are important (obviously). Then Copernicus and Galileo came along and said "wait a minute, my math shows that the earth goes around the sun." Galileo paid for that one. Then, we discovered that our solar system resides in the Milky Way. The center of the Milky Way, of course. Right? Wrong. We're out near the edge, on one of the vast, starry arms of the spiral galaxy. We discovered that we aren't in the only galaxy, but in one, average, medium-sized galaxy out of billions. We're not looking so important, after all, are we? I believe we are lucky to be here, we are lucky to exist as insignificant creatures "on a spinnin' ball in the middle of space" (Train- If It's Love), and we should make the most of it.
Thursday, May 19, 2011
Why?
Many people ask me about what my purpose in life is, what my goals are, and how I go about my life in a way that is fulfilling. Why? Well, I am in an extremely awkward position; a position that I'm sure several other people are experiencing or have experienced in the past. You see, I am an atheist. That, in and of itself, is enough to arouse suspicious curiosity/fear in many of the people I encounter in my life. It's not as though I go about proclaiming my lack of belief. I don't walk around trying to "bring people to the dark side." I simply am not ashamed of it, and when the topic comes up in conversation, as it occasionally does, I speak about it confidently and in a way that I sincerely don't intend to cause contention (even though sometimes it inevitably does). And the situation for me is compounded because I was fortunate enough to be born into a Mormon family, and I grew up smack dab in the middle of Utah Mormon culture. In fact, I still live here. This makes things even more complicated for someone who chooses a secular route, because the religious activity is fervent and plentiful, and the peer pressure to join the "Fold" is almost unbearable, especially when I was an adolescent still in search of who I really was. I want to use this blog to write about how I go through life in the absence of religious belief and ritual. This is actually a very complex subject. As a nonbeliever, I do not have my decisions made for me. I have no holy book to tell me what to do, no pastor or bishop or clergymen to direct me. Of course, I don't want those things, and refuse to accept their validity. Coming up with answers for myself is hard. It requires study and thought and introspection. But isn't that a wonderful part of being alive? I relish searching for answers, and I wouldn't trade my inquisitiveness for anything. Not even 72 virgins.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)