Total Pageviews

Sunday, November 20, 2011

Capitalism vs. Socialism: Educate Yourself

One of the major conundrums that plagues society today is the question of whether capitalism or socialism (or some mix) is the best economic system to adopt. Of course, there are different standards by which economic systems can be judged. For example, is an economic system superior if it allows the most freedom, or if it provides the most people with the most amount of happiness? Or, stated another way, by what ethical standards should we judge economic systems by? Some form of Deontological ethics? Utilitarian ethics? Some other value system? The main point of this post is that making these judgements is not as easy as everyone seems to think it is. I daily encounter individuals who are staunchly conservative or staunchly liberal, and don't seem to have any deep reasoning behind their position. They have simply been indoctrinated and have adopted a worldview, without serious thought about the merits of the opposition. When asked to justify their beliefs, the justifications are usually superficial and rotely memorized. The truly disturbing part of this is that I see it in our politicians as much as I do with everybody else. I for one have no idea which is better. I am not an economist, but I do see the valid arguments on both sides. And I do see how having a "mixed" economy undermines the merits of both, mostly due to the toxic government-corporation relationships that plague the system. I am open to (good) arguments, but plead ignorance on this case at least for now, and so should many others, instead of blindly adopting a system they don't know enough about and defending it to their grave for no other reason than stubbornness. This is an incredibly complex topic which very smart individuals have been disagreeing about for a very long time, and I am cautious whenever I see someone who seems too sure of themselves.




No comments:

Post a Comment