Total Pageviews

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Rejecting the God Hypothesis

So, why don't I believe in god? Is it because I'm heartless? Is it because I am a rebel, someone who enjoys the role of arrogant social pariah?  Is it because I get off arguing with people and telling them that they are wrong?  Is it because I'm trying to hurt my family?  No.  My disbelief stems from none of these things, although at some point in my life every one of them has been proposed as a reason for my apostasy.  The real reason I believe the things I do is that I value objective, skeptical, scientific inquiry whenever I am searching for truth.  I believe this is the best method we have for finding out what the truth is.  This seems to be how most individuals search for truth in most cases, but for some reason, huge numbers of people choose not to hold religion to these standards of inquiry.  A prosecutor must prove the guilt of a criminal in this way.  A researcher must test scientific theories in this way.  God gets a pass.  Why?  And if the standards by which the god hypothesis is tested fall short of even the most basic rigors of honest inquiry, isn't it quite likely that His (for He is, of course, male) existence may be questionable?  That's all I'm saying, really.  I mean, what evidence is there for His existence, anyway?  If we are honestly searching?  As far as I can tell, there are two types of answers that people give: 1) anecdotal, emotionally charged stories and testimonies, and 2) the very fact that we and the world exist is evidence in and of itself.  As far as 1) goes, it is fairly obvious that this type of evidence has no validity.  For one thing, people remember things horribly, and often read meaning into memories and experiences that just has no reason for being there.  Also, there is no clear way to separate these stories into categories of "good" or "bad" or "true" or "false."  As far as truth value goes, your Christian neighbor's claim that god kept him awake when he was drowsing off at the wheel by speaking to him is inseparable from a Muslim's claim that he feels the presence of Allah when he recites the Koran, and inseparable still from a murderer's (perhaps Abraham's) claim that god ordered him to kill.  Sure, the actions that result from each of these claims are different, but how can you say one is true without saying the others are as well?  By what standards are you judging these claims?  Stories like these are and have been prevalent in every society, at all times, involving thousands of different divinities.  They cannot be used to prove god's existence, and if they can, they can be used to prove every god's existence.  With regard to 2), I understand this viewpoint a little more.  I mean, look at the world.  Look at human beings, look at the complex diversity of life around us, look at how earth is set up perfectly to allow living things to flourish.  Isn't it too much of a coincidence to just be luck?  Well, we are pretty lucky, aren't we?  The distance of the earth from the sun, the presence of liquid water, the physical constants of the universe that allow everything to be the way it is, aren't these proof of a divine being setting up conditions for we Homo sapiens to live comfortably?  I wouldn't say so.  This whole line of reasoning is actually. . . unreasonable.  We exist.  Therefore, everything that had to happen to allow us to exist, happened.  Are we lucky to exist?  Sure.  But we do exist.  What are the odds that the earth is just the right distance from the sun?  Well, from where we stand, 100%.  It is the right distance from the sun.  That's why we exist.  The earth doesn't sit at its position so we can exist.  The point of view that the universe is the way it is so we can exist is very egotistical and self-centered.  Not only that, but science continues to make this viewpoint seem more and more foolish.  At first, it was thought that the everything revolved around the earth, because we live on the earth, and we are important (obviously).  Then Copernicus and Galileo came along and said "wait a minute, my math shows that the earth goes around the sun."  Galileo paid for that one.  Then, we discovered that our solar system resides in the Milky Way.  The center of the Milky Way, of course.  Right?  Wrong.  We're out near the edge, on one of the vast, starry arms of the spiral galaxy.  We discovered that we aren't in the only galaxy, but in one, average, medium-sized galaxy out of billions.  We're not looking so important, after all, are we?  I believe we are lucky to be here, we are lucky to exist as insignificant creatures "on a spinnin' ball in the middle of space" (Train- If It's Love), and we should make the most of it.

3 comments:

  1. Your point #1 outlines exactly why I'm a Universalist :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Many religions are mutually exclusive though. . .

    ReplyDelete